The Best Milkshakes in South Jersey
A great burger deserves a great shake, and at Red Barn Burgers, our hand-spun milkshakes are the perfect pairing for our smashed burgers. Thick, creamy, and made to order — no soft-serve machines, no pre-mixed bases, no shortcuts.
Our shakes are spun the old-school way: real ice cream, real milk, blended to the perfect consistency. We offer classic flavors alongside seasonal specials, and every shake is thick enough to stand a straw in. This isn't a fast-food "milkshake" — it's the real thing.
Pair a shake with one of our double smash burgers and a side of hand-cut fries, and you've got one of the best meals in South Jersey. Our chef-owner, a CIA graduate and Philly Burger Brawl winner, built the menu so that every item complements the others — and the shake-burger combo is the crown jewel.
Visit us at the Old Mill Antique Mall in Mullica Hill. Order online at redbarnburgers.com for pickup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the milkshakes hand-spun?
Yes — every milkshake is made to order with real ice cream. No machines, no premixed bases.
What shake flavors do you have?
We offer classic flavors plus rotating seasonal specials. Check our online menu for the current lineup.
Can I add a shake to my online order?
Absolutely. Shakes are available through our online ordering system at redbarnburgers.com.
Visit Us
Red Barn Burgers
47 S Main St (inside Old Mill Antique Mall), Mullica Hill, NJ 08062
Mon–Sat: 11am–8pm | Sun: 11am–7pm
You Might Also Like
The Best Burgers in Mullica Hill, NJ
Red Barn Burgers serves the best burgers in Mullica Hill, NJ — smashed patties made from Certified Angus brisket, chuck & short rib, ground fresh daily on Martin's Famous Potato Rolls. Order online for pickup.
The Best Fries in South Jersey
Red Barn Burgers serves the best hand-cut fries and fresh-cut chips in South Jersey. Made fresh daily in Mullica Hill, NJ. Order online.
The Best Burgers in South Jersey
Red Barn Burgers in Mullica Hill serves the best burgers in South Jersey — Certified Angus brisket, chuck & short rib smashed on a 500° griddle. Award-winning chef. Order online.